Thursday, April 9, 2015


I have previously posted  articles regarding my tween and her cell phone obsession but this article I read, on SAHM.ORG just took me over the top. It felt like it was directed at me and my kid. It list 5 reasons why teens should not have cell phones.  Now, intellectually I know it is not the smartest thing to let your kid have a cell phone, but of course, I let myself get convinced with the, "I am the only one in school who does not have cell phone," routine, by my 12- year old, who is in the 7th grade.

Actually, I have a few friends who had "incidents" recently with their girls and their cell phones, posting inappropriate pictures of themselves and I learned my lesson from them and I became a "watchdog" after those episodes.  Then I got thinking, I know that when you really want to find a way to do something, you do!  So, I figured, it is not so much about watching my kids every move, it is about teaching them (her) that social media is a tool, which can be used for both good and bad.

The last few days and her behavior, lead me to implement  "new rules" in my home regarding my daughter's cell phone usage.  For example, she was texting me during the day with request, such as "bring me lunch please, I don't like the cafeteria food," or "can so and so come over today" or "can I walk to Starbuck's after school?"Can you imagine?  I was getting these texts messages from her during class time, despite her having been warned not to text during class time! (lack of listening skills, is for another blog post!)  Oh, and let's not mention, the "head on the phone" routine in the car upon pick up!

Well, guess what?  this article and all those things I mentioned, set me off!  No more phone in school!

When I shared the news with my daughter when she arrived home yesterday, she just about died.

"What??! that's not fair, she exclaimed!"  "Please Mommy, I have to have my phone in school!"  "Not fair?  I said.  Newsflash! Life is not fair. And not fair, is that your parents pay for your cell phone and you don't. Not fair, is that there are children in this world with no food, no shelter, and definitely no cell phones! So either, you follow my new rules or the phone gets disconnected forever."  SILENCE.

And so, today begins, the new cell phone rule with serious limitations. Sure, I could follow this article's advice and not let her have one at all, but I do not want to be a complete ogre and have her be "the only one without a cell phone."  I do recognize that cell phones are a major way of tweens/teens communicating with each other but with that being said, I also do recognize that I STILL have the power to control her social media and will do so as long as she is under my roof and unable to make wise choices.

I must state publicly, that she is a great kid and a good student, I just want to make sure that her cell phone use and social media does not continue to consume her every waking moment or inhibit her social skills (plus I want her neck muscles to develop properly - LOL!)

The  article below speaks for itself but a few points really struck a nerve with me, and one of those was where it says: "Pediatrician Marjorie Hogan said, “common sense tells me that if a child is laying on his own bed and texting friends instead of getting together” there’s a problem."

Here is the original article as posted in SAHM.ORG:

5 Reasons Your Kid Should Not Have A Cell Phone

I’ll admit it. I’m a dinosaur among my friends because I won’t get my kids a cell phone. My daughters, aged 9 and 11, remind me of that daily with pleas of “I’m the only one without a phone; all my friends have one. Why can’t I?” 
So, because I didn’t want to sound like my mother who always countered with “If everyone was jumping off a bridge, would you do it too?,” I decided to look for a better answer. I was shocked to discover that 21% of children 8 years and younger use smart phones! Wow younger than 8! And 78% of children aged 12 to 17 already have a cell phone.
But before you add your kid to your cellular plan, consider why waiting could be a better option.

1. Privacy Concerns

You may be surprised to find out that only 61% of youth use privacy settings on their social media sites and 52% don’t turn off their location or GPS services. This leaves their locations visible to strangers.
But the scariest revelation to me was that 14% of children have posted their home addresses online.
And before you say, “OH my child would NEVER do anything like that, because we’ve had the “talk” with them; realize this study also revealed that almost 70% of the youth polled admitted to hiding their online activities. Add this to the fact that less than half of the parents are aware of what their child is doing online.

2. Regrets


So what exactly are the kids doing online with their smartphones? Since 1 in 4 teens are “cell-mostly” internet users, saying they mostly go online using their phone, parents need to realize this is their access to the online world. The phones really aren’t just for talking anymore. They are use for texting, surfing, social media, pictures, and yes even sexting.

1 in 4 use their phones primarily as a computer for online access, the other 75% use their tablets or other mobile device. So even if you think they’re not online because they don’t have a phone- ask yourself- do they have a tablet, an iPod, an iPad, a kindle? These need to be monitored just as heavily as smart phones.

The Digital Deception study in 2013 revealed that nearly half of all teens say they’ve posted something online that they later regretted.

This regret can cause more than embarrassment. It can cost careers. Because Onedevice Research discovered that 8% of US people aged 16 to 34 have been turned down for a job because of their social media profile.

And let’s not ignore the regret of Sexting. It’s taken more than one Weiner down (Anthony Weiner, the former US congressman to be exact). And a study performed by USC researchers discovered that 20% of teenagers said they’d received a “sext”, but only about 5% admitted to having sent one.
The July issue of the journal Pediatrics found that among 1,300 middle school students, ranging from 10 to 15 years old and anonymously sampled, that they were more likely to report being sexually active if they also were sending more than 100 texts a day. That drew a direct correlation that stated, “Our results show that excessive, unlimited, or unmonitored texting seems to enable sexting”.
And if that’s not enough, over half of the kids aged 10 to 17 admitted to posting risky comments or photos online. All the while, 25% of them said they use their mobile device to hide this type of online behavior from their parents.

3. Cyber-Bullying

This should probably be at the top of the list because the results of cyber-bullying can lead to a lot more than regrets, job-loss or embarrassment. It can lead to Death!

Wikipedia defines it as the use of information technology to repeatedly harm or harass other people in a deliberate manner. “That may be posting rumors or gossip, but it can elevate to personally identifying victims and publishing material that defames and humiliates them.

This is SERIOUS!

Suicide is the third leading cause of death among young people according to the centers for Disease Control and Prevention. That’s about 4,400 deaths every year! And that doesn’t include the 440,000 suicide attempts that were unsuccessful.

I was appalled at those numbers, and when I read the Cyber-bullying stories online at NoBullying.com, I was even surer of my stance against cell phones for young ones. Many suicides have been the result of cyber-bullying.

4% of the teens polled said they had arguments which started out online from a post but ended up turning into a physical fight. This may not sound like a large number, but when you consider that 43% of teens aged 13 to 17 reports being a victim of “cyber-bullying” in just the past year, you can see how large 4% can actually be.

It’s sad but common. I encourage you to talk to your child about this online form of abuse and how dangerous it can be not only to them, but to those they may harm with an off-handed comment or an unauthorized picture post.

Once online, it’s there forever- even if they think they’ve deleted it.

4. Inhibits True Social Interaction

Because I’m a mom as well as a Sociologist, I was not surprised to learn that all this media time we’re allowing our children to engage in is harming their ability to socialize in real one-on-one interactions.

A study published in the journal Computers in Human Behavior, found that 6th graders who went five days without exposure to technology were significantly better at reading human emotions than kids who had regular access to phones, televisions and computers. It goes on to explain that this finding should be a wake-up call to schools to make sure they’re not just shoving iPads into student’s hands as a teaching method. Instead they need to make sure they’re getting real face to face social interaction and less screen time.

I like how Pediatrician Marjorie Hogan said it, “common sense tells me that if a child is laying on his own bed and texting friends instead of getting together” there’s a problem. The research goes on to indicate that screen time can have negative effects on kids ranging from childhood obesity to irregular sleep patterns and social/behavioral issues.

It makes sense if you think about it. You don’t see kids running around bases or kicking a soccer ball in the net while holding a phone and texting or face-timing. They’re busy exercising, playing social sports and more.

5. Poor Academic Performance and More Anxiety

Several studies have linked frequent cell phone use to lower grades and unhappiness. One study was from researchers from the College of Education Health and Human Services at Kent State University in Ohio on under- graduate students. They linked cell phone usage levels to GPA scores and anxiety levels. The higher a student’s cell phone use, the lower the grades and the higher the anxiety.
Many schools ban students from bringing in cell phones. Since most cell phones are able to look up information online, and can double as calculators and cameras; the ways that a child can use them to their advantage are numerous. It seems that texting has become the new way to “pass notes” in the back of the class.

Even if your child isn’t cheating with his cell phone, if he or she is using it, then they are not listening to the teacher, therefore adding one more distraction to their learning experience.

So, Should Your Child Have a Smart Device?

Hopefully these 5 points have given you some things to think about when deciding why it may be a good idea to wait on giving your child a smart phone.
If you are in the camp that wants your child to have a cell phone for safety purposes, then we would recommend something like:

LG Migo VX1000 Mobile Child Phone
Otherwise, how long you wait depends on many variables and every family is different.
In my house it will depend on the maturity level and responsibility that my child exhibits. It will also depend on costs as I feel owning a phone is a privilege and not a right.
So when she does get a phone, she will have to purchase it herself with her own money. She will have to pay the monthly subscription service. She will sign a contract with her Dad and I that she will not go over in texts or minutes that we set for her and that it will be used appropriately.
Lastly, she will know there will be a parental app that will be monitoring her incoming messages, calls, photos, texts and social media posts. AND we will have all access codes and passwords.

This includes her social media accounts as well. If she breaks our trusts, she will lose the phone.
Obviously as she gets older, the privacy restraints will be lifted as one day we realize she’ll be off to college and able to do many things without her parent’s knowledge…but until then, the same rules that applied while I was growing up will apply to my children.
I hate to say it, but there is a lot of merit in the “As long as you live under my roof, my rules apply” standards.

Whatever you decide, keep in mind that we all only want what’s best for our children. They don’t have to always like us for it, but I guarantee one day they’ll look back and love us for it!

VISIT: https://www.facebook.com/mommywarriorpage

No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank You for Stopping by the Mommy Warrior blog